Ivory brick two-story home with bronze-framed windows, an oak entrance, limestone steps and autumn planting beside a clay-paver walk.

Elmwood Park's Pizza Runs on Recipes That Changed Hands. Here's Who Keeps Them Now.

Old World Pizza has been in a strip mall near the North and Harlem crossroads for about sixty years. The same man has been in its kitchen for more than thirty of them. Amadeo Montalvo kept cooking through at least one change of ownership. When the newest owners took over, they named a sandwich after him.

The sandwich gets the attention, but the story underneath it explains the town. In its October 2026 newsletter, the Village of Elmwood Park ran a full feature on local pizza and called the village "the culinary capital of the area." Most of the kitchens on that list have already been handed from one owner to the next. Customers bought some of them. Grandchildren took over others, and one family moved its recipe here from Taylor Street. Each time, the new people treated the recipe as the one thing they couldn't change.

Old World Pizza was bought by its customers

In September 2024, Danielle Michelon, a Forest Park resident, and her fiancé Patrick Sumara bought Old World Pizza at 7230 W. North Ave. The Forest Park Review reported that the restaurant was at risk of closing at the time. Neither of them had run a restaurant before. Sumara had eaten there for years.

They updated the interior and bought better ingredients. Two things stayed the same: the original thin-crust recipe and Montalvo running the kitchen. Michelon told the paper the cheese is a house blend they mix themselves, the dough is made in-house, and the sauce is "perfectly in the middle," neither too sweet nor too acidic.

The new menu items build on the old kitchen. The Amadeo sub is stacked with ham, pepperoni and Italian beef, then topped with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, American and mozzarella, with hot giardiniera or jalapeños. Michelon called it Montalvo's invention, "like a kitchen-sink of Italian sandwiches." There is also a double-deck pie: two thin crusts stacked with toppings between them and braided together at the edge.

Michelon summed up their position this way: "even though Old World Pizza has been around here forever, we are a new kid on the block." The restaurant is open seven days a week.

Pompei brought its recipe from Taylor Street

Old World shows new owners keeping a recipe in its original building. Pompei, at 22 Conti Pkwy. on the Circle, shows a family keeping its recipe while changing buildings.

Pompei started on Taylor Street. The Wednesday Journal reported that owner Ralph Davino grew up above the original location, where the family ran a bakery on one side of a six-flat and a tavern on the other. He took over in 1984 and added sausage and pepperoni pizza, sandwiches, and the savory "strudels" that now come in about a dozen varieties. Pompei once had six locations. By the time the Elmwood Park opportunity came up, it was down to one.

Davino explained why he picked Elmwood Park in that same article. When the University of Illinois's Chicago campus expanded in the 1960s, many Italian families left Taylor Street's Little Italy, and many of them settled in the Elmwood Park area. Opening on the Circle brought the restaurant to where many of its customers' families had already moved.

The space was a Jewel grocery store, then a convenience store, before the family gut-rehabbed it. Grandson Lucian DiPofi manages the location. "Our pizzas – it's on the same dough that we've been making forever," DiPofi told the Wednesday Journal. Davino said his best item is still the one the business started with, cheese pizza.

Circle Tavern built a new identity around the recipes it got right

A few doors from Pompei, Circle Tavern at 18 W. Conti Pkwy. shows another way to take over. Michael Jardine grew up in Elmwood Park. In July 2026 he told the Wednesday Journal that he was six years into owning the tavern.

He changed the room more than the founders of Old World or Pompei ever would have. He described the tavern he inherited as "a late-night place with a pool table and dartboard." He has turned it into somewhere a family can eat on a Friday night and adults can come back without the kids on Saturday. His approach to the food was gradual. He perfected the burgers and pizza first, then rebuilt the chicken, which is now breaded and battered in-house.

The pizza is flatbread. The Village newsletter points to the Sweet Heat and the Vodka con Salsiccia and recommends the gluten-free thin crust. According to the Wednesday Journal's July piece, Mondays bring half-price pizza and Fridays are fried chicken night. The paper also reported that Christmastime "gets the full treatment" in the decorations.

North Avenue shows how far back the handoffs go

The three Circle and Harlem stories are recent. The older pizzerias on North Avenue show the same habit stretching back decades. In the table, the second column is the restaurant's starting point and the third is the most recent handoff on record.

Restaurant Where it started Who runs it now
Jim & Pete's, 7806 W. North Ave. Founded in 1941 by Jim Sorce Sr. and his brother-in-law Pete Pizo Michael Bucchianeri, named as owner by the Forest Park Review in 2024
Armand's Pizzeria, 7650 W. North Ave. Childhood friends Michael Caringella and Armand Christopher bought the Victory Tap in 1956, and Caringella brought his family recipes Still promoted under the Armand's name in 2026
Spizzico, 7446 W. North Ave. Started by the Spizzirri family Rocco Spizzirri took ownership in May 2021
Massa Café Italiano, 7434 W. North Ave. Run by Giovanna and Angelo Lollino Angelo Lollino, owner and chef
Old World Pizza, 7230 W. North Ave. Opened in the 1960s near North and Harlem Danielle Michelon and Patrick Sumara since September 2024

According to the Jim & Pete's history, the restaurant has been around for more than 80 years, and a 2024 Forest Park Review feature quoted owner Michael Bucchianeri on keeping its traditions. The Village newsletter says its thin crust is "regularly voted by many as the best thin crust pizzas in town," and that it also has a white-tablecloth dining room for when you have time to sit down. Armand's began in an old tap room. The Village points to its buttery thin crust and the yardstick pizza, which serves 8 to 12 people. Spizzico's Forest Park Review profile describes a family business where relatives still help run the room. Massa's Sicilian-style bakery pizza has a focaccia-like crust flavored with olive oil. The Village suggests finishing with an affogato made with house-roasted espresso.

All five of these were promoted at their North Avenue addresses during the February 2026 Elmwood Park Restaurant Week, along with Pompei on the Circle.

A Holiday Stroll evening, three weeks out

The Village's annual tree lighting and Holiday Stroll is Friday, December 4, from 5 to 7 p.m. at Conti Circle. The Village newsletter says Public Works will put up "thousands of lights around Conti Parkway." Trustee Bina Conte, quoted in the same newsletter, said "there's always the chance that Mr. Claus will show up."

Both of the Circle's handed-down kitchens are within walking distance of the tree, so the evening can be built around them:

  1. Before the lighting, around 4 p.m. Eat early at Pompei, 22 Conti Pkwy. DiPofi's advice for first-timers is the cheese pizza or the gnocchi with vodka sauce.
  2. 5 to 7 p.m. Walk the Circle for the lights and the Stroll.
  3. After the lighting. Circle Tavern, 18 W. Conti Pkwy., keeps Friday hours until midnight according to the Wednesday Journal's July listing. That article also described the holiday decorations as getting the full treatment.
  4. For a family table at home that weekend. Order a double-deck pie from Old World on North Avenue, or a yardstick from Armand's if the group is big enough to need one.

Two new names are also on the way. Ethos Taverna, a Greek restaurant from Forte Hospitality Group, is coming to 7528 W. North Ave. with charcoal-grilled meats and whole fish, meze and Greek wine. Elmwood Cafe has announced 16 Conti Pkwy. as its address, a short walk from Pompei and Circle Tavern.

Old buildings and old recipes changing hands is what Antonio Sarmiento watches for in every Elmwood Park sale, and the best stories usually start with a new owner who decided to keep something intact. If you've got a pizzeria tradition in town worth adding to this list, or a question about what the Circle's newest storefronts mean for your block, Let's Connect.

Work With Antonio

Real estate should feel straightforward and personal. You’ll get honest guidance, a clear plan, and someone who pays attention to the details that matter to you. From start to finish, everything is handled with care so the process feels smooth—and the outcome feels right.

Follow Me on Instagram